Wait til you hear this blog

The Difference Between Criminal Offenses, Civil Violations, and Contempt of Court

October 21, 2026•19 min read

Legal Empowerment, High-Conflict Personalities, Documentation Tools

The Difference Between Criminal Offenses, Civil Violations, and Contempt of Court

Have you ever opened your banking app during a divorce and discovered that a significant amount of money has suddenly disappeared? Maybe your spouse withdrew thousands of dollars from a joint account without telling you. Perhaps your ex secretly recorded a conversation, spread damaging and untrue statements about you, or repeatedly ignored the parenting arrangements you thought you had agreed upon.

Your first reaction might be, “They can't do that. Isn't that illegal?”

I understand why you would feel that way. When you are dealing with a high-conflict divorce or a difficult ex, it can feel as though the other person is getting away with everything. You see behavior that seems dishonest, unfair, or completely unacceptable, and you naturally expect there to be consequences.

But there is something important I want you to understand: not everything that is wrong is a crime, and not everything that is illegal leads to an arrest. Depending on the circumstances, the behavior may create a civil claim, violate an existing court order, or potentially involve a criminal offense. Sometimes, the same conduct can raise more than one legal issue.

I'm Rebecca Zung, The Leverage Lawyer, a bestselling author and the founder of SLAY AI. After years of working with high-conflict situations, I have seen how confusing these distinctions can be, especially when emotions are running high and you are trying to protect your finances, your reputation, and your relationship with your children.

Understanding the difference between a criminal offense, a civil violation, and contempt of court can help you stop reacting to what your ex is doing and start identifying the legal remedy that may actually help you.

What Is the Difference Between Criminal Law, Civil Law, and Contempt of Court?

The first step is understanding that these are different legal concepts, even though they can sometimes overlap.

A criminal offense is generally considered an offense against the state or government. Prosecutors pursue criminal charges on behalf of the government, and a conviction can result in penalties such as fines, probation, or incarceration, depending on the offense. In a criminal case, the prosecution generally must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

A civil case, on the other hand, usually concerns legal rights and remedies between individuals or organizations. Rather than focusing primarily on criminal punishment, a civil proceeding may seek compensation for financial losses, repayment of money, or a court order requiring someone to do something or stop doing something.

Divorce and child custody proceedings are generally civil matters. That does not mean the conduct involved can never be criminal. It means that the family law case and any potential criminal case may involve different legal questions, procedures, and consequences.

Then there is contempt of court.

Civil contempt generally involves failing to comply with an existing court order. Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, a court may impose measures intended to secure compliance, compensate the affected party, or address the violation. Serious consequences can sometimes include financial sanctions or confinement.

The key distinction is that contempt is connected to the authority of the court and the obligation to follow its orders. A person can behave unfairly without violating a court order, and a person can violate a court order without necessarily committing a separate criminal offense.

That distinction matters because the legal remedy you pursue should match the actual problem.

Is It Illegal for Your Ex to Take Money From a Joint Bank Account?

Let's start with a situation I have seen many times in family law disputes.

Imagine that you and your spouse have $20,000 in a joint bank account. You check the balance one morning and discover that $18,000 has been withdrawn. Suddenly, you are worried about how you are going to pay your bills, cover the mortgage, or afford the expenses associated with the divorce.

You may immediately think your spouse has stolen your money.

I understand that reaction. Discovering that a large amount of money has disappeared can be frightening, particularly when you are already dealing with the uncertainty of a divorce.

However, there is an important distinction between having permission to withdraw money from a bank account and having the legal right to keep all of that money.

If both account holders have withdrawal authority, the bank may permit either person to withdraw funds without the other person's approval. That fact alone does not necessarily establish theft or another criminal offense.

Depending on the circumstances, the withdrawal could potentially raise a civil claim, including a claim involving the improper taking or use of funds. Criminal liability would depend on additional facts and whether the conduct satisfies the elements of an applicable criminal statute.

But even if the withdrawal is not criminal, that does not mean your spouse gets to keep the money without consequences.

During a divorce, the court may need to account for the withdrawn funds when dividing marital assets and liabilities. If the money was improperly spent, dissipated, or removed in circumstances that justify an adjustment, the court may consider how to account for that amount in the financial division. The result depends on the applicable law, the source and use of the funds, and the evidence.

For example, if one spouse withdrew $18,000 from a joint account, the financial accounting may need to reflect that withdrawal so that the parties' respective interests can be evaluated fairly.

The important point is that the bank allowing a transaction does not automatically determine who is ultimately entitled to the money in a divorce.

What If Your Ex Drains a Bank Account After the Divorce Is Filed?

The situation can become more serious if a divorce has already been filed and a standing order or other court order restricts how the parties can use or transfer their assets.

In some jurisdictions, orders that take effect when a divorce is filed require spouses to maintain the financial status quo, subject to specified exceptions. Such orders may permit ordinary expenses while restricting unusual withdrawals, transfers, or the dissipation of assets.

If your spouse drains a joint account in violation of an applicable order, you may have grounds to ask the court to enforce that order or consider a contempt proceeding.

Depending on the facts and the law, possible remedies may include financial adjustments, sanctions, or attorney's fees.

This is why I encourage people to look beyond the question, “Was that theft?” A more useful question may be, “What legal obligations applied at the time, what evidence shows that they were violated, and what remedy can I ask the court to consider?”

That is how you begin turning a frightening financial situation into a concrete legal strategy.

Is Secretly Recording Your Ex Illegal?

Secret recordings are another issue that comes up frequently in high-conflict divorce and family law disputes.

You might discover that your ex recorded a conversation without telling you. Perhaps you were discussing your children, your finances, or the terms of your separation. You may feel violated, angry, or concerned about how the recording will be used.

But whether recording a conversation is legal depends on the applicable law and the specific circumstances.

Some jurisdictions generally allow a participant in a conversation to record it without obtaining the other participants' consent. These are commonly described as one-party consent jurisdictions.

Other jurisdictions generally require the consent of all parties to certain private conversations, subject to applicable exceptions. Florida, for example, generally has an all-party consent requirement for covered private communications, while New York generally follows a one-party consent rule.

The precise rules can depend on the type of communication, the circumstances of the recording, and other legal exceptions. You should not assume that a recording is lawful or unlawful based solely on the fact that you did not know about it.

There is also an important difference between recording a conversation in which you participate and secretly recording other people when you are not present.

When evaluating a recording, I want you to consider three separate questions.

First, was the recording lawful to make? Second, was it lawful to share, distribute, or play for someone else? Third, can it be admitted as evidence in a legal proceeding?

Those questions are related, but they are not identical.

Even when a recording exists, questions about authenticity and admissibility may arise. A court may need to consider whether the recording is genuine, whether it accurately represents the conversation, how it was obtained, and whether the applicable rules permit its use as evidence.

If your ex has secretly recorded you, do not automatically assume that the recording is illegal, that it can be used against you, or that it will necessarily be excluded from court. Get advice based on the law that applies to your circumstances before deciding how to respond.

The same principle applies if you are considering recording your ex. Before you do so, understand the relevant consent and privacy laws.

Can You Sue Your Ex for Defamation for Spreading Lies About You?

High-conflict relationships can involve smear campaigns, damaging accusations, and attempts to influence how other people perceive you.

Your ex might tell friends, relatives, professional contacts, or other people that you are dishonest, irresponsible, or incapable of being a good parent. In some situations, the accusations may be completely false and could cause serious personal or professional harm.

It is understandable to want the person to face consequences. But damaging someone's reputation does not automatically make a statement defamatory, and defamation is generally handled as a civil claim rather than an ordinary criminal prosecution.

Defamation law varies by jurisdiction, but a claim commonly requires proof of a false statement of fact communicated to another person, together with the applicable fault and harm requirements. The exact elements depend on the circumstances, including the nature of the statement and the people involved.

Consider the difference between someone saying, “I thought they were a terrible spouse,” and someone making a specific, false factual accusation, such as claiming that you stole money from your employer.

The first statement may be an opinion. The second is a factual allegation that could potentially support a defamation claim if the other legal requirements are satisfied.

The distinction matters because not every cruel, insulting, or unfair statement creates a viable legal claim.

You also need to consider what harm you can establish and how you can connect that harm to the statement. For example, suppose a potential client decides not to work with you because someone made a false factual accusation about your professional conduct. If you can demonstrate that the statement caused the lost business and establish the relevant financial loss, that evidence may help support your claim.

Other forms of reputational harm can be more difficult to quantify, and the damages required depend on the applicable law and the type of claim.

This does not mean you should ignore a smear campaign. It means you should be strategic about documenting what happened, identifying who received the statements, preserving relevant communications, and determining whether the conduct supports a legal remedy.

Instead of focusing only on how unfair the statements are, ask what was actually said, whether it was a false statement of fact, who heard or received it, and what harm you can demonstrate.

That is a much stronger starting point for evaluating your options.

Is Breaking a Parenting Agreement Contempt of Court?

Parenting disputes can be particularly frustrating because they involve your children, your time with them, and your ability to maintain consistency in their lives.

Imagine that you and your ex exchange text messages agreeing to swap weekends. Later, your ex changes their mind and refuses to follow through.

You might immediately think, “They agreed to this. They can't just change their mind. That's contempt of court.”

But contempt of what order?

This is where the details matter.

An informal agreement made through text messages does not automatically modify an existing court order. If the parenting plan or custody order specifies particular dates, times, or responsibilities, you need to examine what that order actually requires and whether the conduct violated it.

Your text messages may still be relevant. They can help establish what was discussed, what was agreed upon, and how the other parent communicated with you. Depending on the circumstances, they may also contribute to a broader pattern of behavior that could be relevant to a future request to modify a parenting plan.

However, the existence of an agreement between the parents does not automatically mean that changing it constitutes contempt.

If there is a clear court order and your ex repeatedly fails to comply with it, the situation may be different. Depending on the order and the applicable law, you may be able to seek enforcement or ask the court to consider contempt.

A repeated pattern of noncompliance may also be relevant to questions about co-parenting and whether a parenting arrangement should be modified. A modification generally requires the applicable legal standard to be met, which may include showing a substantial change in circumstances.

This is why I recommend keeping accurate records of parenting-related incidents. Preserve the messages, note what happened, record the relevant dates, and distinguish between what the court order requires and what you and your ex discussed informally.

You want to be able to demonstrate a pattern with specific facts rather than simply telling the court that your ex is impossible to work with.

Is Lying During a Divorce Perjury?

Another common source of frustration is discovering that your ex has lied about money, income, bonuses, expenses, or other important facts.

Perhaps your spouse says there was no bonus at work this year, even though you believe they received one. Maybe you suspect that they are hiding income or misrepresenting their financial situation.

It is tempting to assume that every lie during a divorce is perjury. But that is not how the law generally works.

Perjury generally involves knowingly making a materially false statement under oath or in another legally covered sworn declaration. The precise requirements depend on the applicable law.

For example, a knowingly false material statement in a financial affidavit may raise serious legal concerns if the requirements for perjury or another applicable offense are satisfied.

But an ordinary lie told in a private conversation is not automatically perjury simply because it is untrue.

That does not mean dishonesty is irrelevant to a divorce case.

If you can establish that your ex made false statements about important financial matters, the evidence may affect how their credibility is evaluated. Depending on the circumstances, it may also support requests for additional financial disclosure, enforcement of an order, sanctions, or other appropriate relief.

Credibility matters in legal proceedings because judges must evaluate the evidence presented by both sides. When a person's statements are contradicted by reliable records or by their own previous communications, those inconsistencies may be relevant to the court's assessment.

The key is to distinguish between what you suspect, what you can prove, and what legal consequences may follow from the evidence.

Rather than simply accusing your ex of lying, identify the specific statement, preserve the document or communication that contradicts it, and determine why the discrepancy matters to the legal issues before the court.

Specific, organized evidence is generally more useful than a broad accusation that someone is dishonest.

Why Doesn't Anyone Stop Your Ex From Getting Away With Everything?

If you are dealing with a high-conflict ex, you may have asked yourself this question more times than you can count.

How can they take the money, ignore the rules, spread lies, or repeatedly create problems without anyone stepping in to stop them?

One of the hardest realities of a legal dispute is that there is no automatic system that intervenes every time someone behaves badly.

There is no one who will necessarily appear at your door or at a custody exchange to stop your ex the moment they do something unfair. In many situations, you have to identify the potential violation, gather the relevant evidence, determine the appropriate legal remedy, and take the necessary procedural steps to bring the issue before the court.

That may involve filing a motion, requesting enforcement, seeking a contempt finding when legally appropriate, or pursuing another available remedy. You may also need to attend a hearing and present evidence that supports the relief you are requesting.

The court needs more than your understandable frustration. It needs facts, evidence, and a legally supported reason to take the action you are asking it to take.

This is why it is so important to understand the difference between a criminal offense, a civil claim, and a violation of a court order.

If you approach every incident as though it must be a crime, you may spend time pursuing a remedy that does not fit the circumstances. If you assume that nothing can be done because your ex has not been arrested, you may overlook important civil remedies or enforcement options.

Your goal is not simply to prove that your ex behaved badly. Your goal is to identify what happened, establish what you can prove, and determine what outcome the law may allow you to seek.

That is where strategy becomes more important than reaction

How to Document Your Ex's Behavior and Build Leverage

When you are dealing with a high-conflict legal dispute, documentation can be an important part of building a clear and persuasive case.

Start by preserving the original evidence. This may include bank statements, financial records, text messages, emails, parenting communications, court orders, and other documents relevant to the incident.

Create a timeline that identifies what happened and when. Record the date of each incident, what your ex did or said, which document supports your account, and how the event relates to the issue you may need to address legally.

For example, if your ex withdrew money from a joint account, preserve the relevant account statements and transaction records. If the concern involves a parenting schedule, keep the messages and compare the actual events with the requirements of the current order. If your ex made a statement that you believe was false, preserve the original communication and any reliable evidence that contradicts it.

Try to separate facts from assumptions. Instead of writing, “My ex is trying to destroy me financially,” document the actual withdrawal, the date it occurred, the amount involved, and any relevant order or communication.

This approach helps you move from a general feeling that something is wrong to a record of specific events that can be evaluated.

It can also help you and your attorney identify patterns, inconsistencies, and potential violations that might otherwise be difficult to see when information is scattered across emails, text messages, bank statements, and other records.

This is one of the reasons I created SLAY AI. The platform is designed to help users track incidents, organize documentation and communications, identify patterns and discrepancies, and develop timelines and exhibits that can assist them and their attorneys in preparing for legal disputes. You can explore it at SLAYPRO.AI.

Technology can help organize information, but it does not replace legal advice. Any evidence prepared for use in court should be reviewed for accuracy, relevance, authenticity, and compliance with the applicable rules.

The purpose of documentation is not to collect every upsetting interaction simply because it happened. It is to preserve the information that helps explain what occurred, why it matters, and what remedy may be appropriate.

That is a far more useful approach than allowing every new incident to pull you into another emotional battle.

Stop Asking Only, "How Are They Getting Away With This?"

When you are in the middle of a high-conflict divorce, it is easy to become consumed by the question of why your ex has not faced consequences.

You may feel that the system is unfair, that nobody understands what you are experiencing, or that the other person knows exactly how to manipulate the situation.

I want you to shift your focus.

Instead of asking only, “How are they getting away with this?” begin asking, “What exactly happened? What can I prove? What legal obligation applied? And what remedy fits the situation?”

Was there potentially a criminal offense? Is there a civil claim? Did your ex violate an existing court order? Could the conduct be relevant to the division of assets, the enforcement of a parenting plan, or your ex's credibility in court?

Sometimes, more than one of these questions will matter. Other times, the conduct may be deeply upsetting without meeting the legal requirements for the remedy you initially imagined.

Understanding the distinction helps you make more informed decisions about your next steps.

It also helps you direct your energy toward what you can control. You cannot control every decision your ex makes, and you cannot guarantee how a court will rule. But you can work to preserve evidence, understand your legal options, communicate strategically, and prepare a clear presentation of the facts.

That is how you begin to move from feeling powerless to building leverage.

Final Thoughts: The Right Legal Remedy Starts With Knowing the Difference

If your ex has taken money from a joint bank account, secretly recorded a conversation, spread damaging statements about you, violated a parenting order, or made false statements in a legal proceeding, do not assume that every situation falls into the same legal category.

A criminal offense, a civil violation, and contempt of court involve different legal questions and potentially different consequences. The facts, the applicable law, the existence of a court order, and the evidence available will all influence which remedies may be appropriate.

You do not have to minimize what happened simply because it may not be a crime. At the same time, you do not want to pursue a legal strategy based solely on the assumption that something unfair must be criminal.

Get clear about the facts. Preserve the evidence. Understand the order or legal obligation involved. Work with a qualified attorney to identify the remedy that fits your circumstances and the result you want to achieve.

Because in a high-conflict legal dispute, feeling that you are right and being able to demonstrate why the law supports your position are two different things.

The more clearly you understand that distinction, the better equipped you will be to make strategic decisions, protect your interests, and build leverage.

If you are facing a difficult legal situation, remember this question: Is it a crime, a civil issue, a violation of a court order, or some combination of these? What can I prove, and what remedy actually fits?

Start there, and you can begin turning frustration into a more focused plan of action.

If you want more practical strategies for navigating high-conflict negotiations, divorce, custody disputes, and difficult legal situations, explore my resources and learn how to build leverage without allowing conflict to control your life.

And remember: Leverage plus clarity equals freedom.

— Rebecca Zung

The Leverage Lawyer

Back to Blog

Welcome to Your New World of Winning

Grab Your Free

Your AI-Powered

Negotiation Advantage

Rebecca Zung Esq is a globally recognized high conflict negotiation expert, an attorney recognized as Best Lawyer by US News, and USA Today Bestselling Author.

Other Ways to Connect

Social Media

Rebecca Zung LLC | 2026