
Staying Lessons in Manipulation and Deception
Everybody wants to know how Elizabeth Holmes went from building a company valued at billions of dollars to being convicted of fraud and sentenced to prison. But when I look at the story through the lens of more than 26 years as a trial lawyer and my experience dealing with high conflict personalities, I see something even more important. I see a playbook of manipulation, borrowed credibility, secrecy, intimidation, and a refusal to take accountability. And if you are dealing with a narcissist, a manipulative ex, or someone who seems to get away with everything, there are some powerful lessons here that may help you understand what is happening and, more importantly, what you can do about it.
The documentary You Can See Everything offers a closer look at the Elizabeth Holmes story. But there are things I want you to understand beyond what you see on the screen. In high conflict situations, people often become so focused on the outrageous behavior that they miss the underlying strategy. They see the lies, the accusations, the intimidation, and the damage, and they wonder how anyone could possibly get away with it. They start asking when the other person will finally be exposed, when everyone will see the truth, or when that person will admit what they did.
Here is what I have learned: you cannot build your strategy around waiting for someone to confess, apologize, or acknowledge the truth. You need to understand the patterns, preserve the evidence, and build a record that can stand on its own.
The First Manipulation Tactic: Borrowing Credibility
One of the first things that stood out to me about Elizabeth Holmes was the way she appeared to borrow credibility from other people and organizations. Instead of relying solely on the actual performance of her technology, she created an impression of support and endorsement from major pharmaceutical companies.
This is a tactic I call borrowing credibility. A manipulator may not have enough credibility on their own, so they attempt to attach themselves to people, institutions, professionals, or organizations that others already trust. They use those associations to make their claims seem more legitimate than they actually are.
You may recognize this in your own high conflict situation. Perhaps your ex says that every attorney agrees with them, that the therapist is on their side, or that everyone knows you are the problem. They may repeatedly invoke other people's opinions without providing any actual proof.
The purpose is to make you feel outnumbered and question your own position. When someone tells you that everybody agrees with them, you may start wondering whether you are missing something. You may even feel pressured to defend yourself against an invisible group of people.
But there is a simple way to approach this: ask for specifics. Who said it? What exactly did they say? Is there a document, message, or other evidence supporting the claim?
Do not automatically accept someone else's version of what other people supposedly think. Credibility is not established by name dropping or repeating that everyone agrees. It must be supported by facts.
How Manipulators Build Systems That Prevent Accountability
The second pattern I noticed was the creation of a system in which people could not easily check what was happening. In the Theranos story, departments were separated, information was restricted, and employees were not necessarily able to see what was happening elsewhere in the organization.
When there are no meaningful checks and balances, it becomes much easier for misinformation and deception to continue. People may have only fragments of the truth, while the person controlling the information maintains influence over the larger narrative.
I see a similar dynamic in high conflict relationships and family disputes. A manipulative person may tell different stories to different people. They may keep family members, professionals, friends, or coworkers from communicating with one another. They may use flying monkeys, triangulation, and smear campaigns to create distrust between people.
One person hears one version of events. Someone else hears a completely different version. Before long, everyone is reacting to information that may be incomplete or deliberately distorted.
This can leave you feeling isolated and confused. You may spend enormous amounts of energy trying to correct what someone has said about you, while the other person continues moving between different audiences and controlling the information each one receives.
The lesson is to look for the larger pattern. Do not focus only on one conversation or one accusation. Pay attention to whether stories change depending on the audience, whether people are being discouraged from communicating, and whether there is a consistent effort to keep information separate.
When possible and appropriate, preserve the original communications and rely on firsthand information rather than rumors or secondhand interpretations.
When the Truth Becomes Too Expensive to Tell
Another important pattern in the Elizabeth Holmes story was the use of confidentiality agreements, legal pressure, and other barriers that made speaking up feel risky for employees.
In a high conflict relationship, the same dynamic can happen in different ways. Someone may make the financial cost of challenging them seem overwhelming. They may threaten litigation, threaten to turn children or family members against you, or make you believe that speaking up will create consequences you cannot afford.
Eventually, you may start thinking that it is easier to stay quiet.
This is one of the reasons people remain stuck in high conflict situations for so long. They are not necessarily unaware of what is happening. They may see the manipulation clearly, but they feel trapped by the potential consequences of doing anything about it.
You might think, "I cannot afford another legal battle," or "What if my children believe what this person is saying?" You may worry that telling the truth will make the situation even worse.
I want you to understand that feeling intimidated does not mean you are powerless. It means you need a thoughtful strategy. You need to understand your options, evaluate the risks, preserve relevant evidence, and seek appropriate professional guidance before making decisions.
You do not have to react to every threat. You do not have to announce every move you are considering. Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do is quietly get organized and understand your position.
Why High Conflict People Double Down Instead of Taking Accountability
Another behavior worth examining is the refusal to acknowledge wrongdoing. When someone is confronted with information that contradicts their story, you might expect them to reconsider, correct the record, or take responsibility.
But in high conflict situations, that does not always happen.
Sometimes the person doubles down. They repeat the same claim with even more conviction, even when there are emails, contracts, messages, or other records that contradict what they are saying.
This can be incredibly destabilizing. When someone repeats a false version of events often enough, other people may begin to believe it. You may even start questioning your own memory.
That is one of the ways gaslighting can operate. The person keeps insisting that their version is correct, and you find yourself spending more and more time trying to prove that something happened the way you remember it.
You need to recognize that arguing with someone who is committed to their own narrative may not produce accountability. You can explain yourself ten different ways and still receive the same denial.
Instead of trying to force an admission, shift your attention to what can be established. What was said? When was it said? What happened afterward? Is there a written record? Does the person's current explanation contradict something they previously put in writing?
Your goal is not to win an endless argument. Your goal is to establish a clear and credible record.
What Actually Exposes Deception? Documents and Contradictions.
This is perhaps the biggest lesson from the Elizabeth Holmes case.
The downfall of Theranos was not simply a matter of public outrage or people expressing their opinions about Elizabeth Holmes. A critical part of the case involved internal documents and records that contradicted what had been represented to investors.
The record mattered.
In high conflict divorce, business disputes, and other legal situations, this distinction is incredibly important. You may know that someone is lying. You may know that they have manipulated you. You may have a long history of experiences that make their behavior obvious to you.
But knowing something happened and being able to demonstrate it persuasively are two different things.
A judge, mediator, attorney, or other decision maker needs more than your frustration. They need relevant facts and evidence. A written message that contradicts a later statement may be more useful than pages of emotional explanations. A documented timeline may reveal a pattern that is difficult to see when each incident is considered separately.
This is why I say: Data, not drama. Patterns equal proof.
That does not mean every document automatically proves wrongdoing or that every contradiction establishes a legal violation. Evidence must be authentic, relevant, properly preserved, and evaluated in context. But a clear record can help you move beyond competing stories and demonstrate what actually happened.
Firsthand Knowledge Can Be More Powerful Than You Think
Another important part of the Theranos story involved two young employees who had specific firsthand knowledge and brought information to someone who could investigate it.
They did not necessarily have the greatest status or influence in the room. What mattered was that they knew something specific because they had direct experience with what was happening.
This is an important lesson if you feel as though the other person has all the power. You may not have their money, reputation, connections, or ability to control the narrative. But you may have firsthand knowledge, original communications, and records that can help establish the facts.
The key is to distinguish what you personally observed from what someone else told you. Preserve the original documents. Keep dates and details accurate. Avoid embellishing or making assumptions about someone's motives.
If you are dealing with a legal dispute, work with your attorney to understand which information is relevant and how it should be presented. You do not need to become louder than the other person. You need to become clearer and more organized.
What the Elizabeth Holmes Verdict Actually Means
It is also important to be precise about the legal outcome. Elizabeth Holmes was convicted by a jury on one count of conspiracy to defraud investors and three counts of wire fraud against investors. She was acquitted on the four counts involving patients.
An acquittal does not mean that nothing happened. It means the government did not prove those particular charges beyond a reasonable doubt. The distinction matters because legal outcomes depend on the specific charges, evidence, and burden of proof.
This is another lesson for anyone involved in a high conflict legal dispute. Do not confuse what you believe happened with what can be established under the applicable legal standard. Understanding that distinction helps you build a stronger, more realistic strategy.
Stop Waiting to Be Believed. Start Building the Record.
If you are dealing with a narcissist or a high conflict personality, one of the most exhausting experiences can be feeling as though nobody believes you. You may spend months or years trying to get someone to understand what happened. You may keep explaining, defending, and justifying yourself because you believe that if you can just find the right words, everyone will finally see the truth.
But what if you stopped waiting for that moment?
What if, instead, you started documenting what happens as it happens?
Write down the date, the event, what was said, who was present, and what evidence exists. Save relevant emails, text messages, agreements, and other original records. Keep your notes factual. Separate what you observed from what you suspect. Follow your attorney's guidance about preserving and sharing information, especially if there are court orders, privacy concerns, or confidentiality obligations.
I created SLAY AI to help people who are struggling to organize information, identify patterns, and build a more structured understanding of their high conflict situations. It is designed to help you work with your information and develop clearer, more strategic communication. You can get started for free at SLAYPRO.AI.
The point is not to collect documents just for the sake of collecting them. The point is to understand what matters, identify contradictions, and create a clear record that supports your position.
You Do Not Need Their Confession to Move Forward
At the end of the day, one of the most important lessons from the Elizabeth Holmes story is that you may never get the admission you are waiting for. You may never hear the other person say, "I was wrong." They may never acknowledge the damage they caused. They may continue insisting that their version of events is the truth.
You cannot build your future around waiting for someone else to become accountable.
What you can do is build a record that is clear, organized, and persuasive. You can stop reacting to every provocation. You can stop trying to convince everyone. You can focus on the people who actually need accurate information and the decisions that truly matter.
When you are dealing with a high conflict person, remember this: the loudest person is not necessarily the most credible person. The person who repeats a story the most is not necessarily telling the truth. And the person who appears to have control today may not have control when the facts are carefully examined.
Document what happens. Look for patterns. Preserve the evidence. Build your strategy.
You may never get the confession you want, but you can still build the clarity and leverage you need to move forward.
— Rebecca Zung
The Leverage Lawyer

